Flexor tendon rehabilitation in the 21st century: A systematic review
Filed under Treatments
Neiduski, R. L. & Powell, R. K. (2019). Flexor tendon rehabilitation in the 21st century: A systematic review. Journal of Hand Therapy, 32, 165-174.
The Skinny
The objective of the study was to determine if there was evidence to support 1 type of exercise regimen. Exercise regimens reviewed include place and holds, early passive or true active. The inclusion criteria included anything published after the year 2000 and study outcomes measure had to include range of motion.
The articles were grouped into three separate categories and these included
- Early passive (which included Kleinert protocol and Duran Protocol flexor tendon repair)
- Place and holds- includes isometric hold of the involved digit in flexion (Indiana protocol flexor tendon repair)
- True Active range of motion: those who initiated early active movement within the first week
In the Weeds
Of the 241 articles identified only 9 meet the inclusion criteria and only 8 were on adults. Of the eight, 4 compared early passive motion to place and holds. These studies yielded that places and hold had better results than passive range of motion protocols.
The remaining 4 compared early active motion flexor tendon protocol with a least one other range of motion protocol. No definitive conclusions could be made.
Brining It Home
Only one of the articles clearly stated a repair strength of 4 strands should be utilized when initiating early active. Meaning if you only have a 2-strand repair, it is not safe to perform early active. It is important to review the literature on repair strength before advancing the patient. Many of the patient’s outcomes measures were all performed at the 12-week mark which does not consider those patients who may have had gapping and late rupture.
The review supported using place and holds over passive flexion protocols. This information conflicts with the work done by Dr. Lalonde showing a buckle and jerk at the edge of the pulley with performing place and holds.
No support could be drawn as to if early active was superior to place and holds.
No strong conclusions could be made based on the review as to which exercise regime yields the best outcome.
The article review is helpful in knowing that despite recommendation for early active motion we do not have high level evidence supporting its use. However, this does not consider clinical experience and expert opinion. It is believed that early active is the superior intervention based on recommendation by the American Association of Hand Surgery and the Maintenance of Certification. The literature review leaves you with several questions as to which treatment to utilize in the clinic. It is difficult to compare post-operative exercise regimes as there are many variables to account for in treating flexor tendon repairs. Treating flexor tendon injuries is truly the blending of science and art.
More To Read
Sensory Processing in People With and Without Tendinopathy
Emilee Sanders, OTS Sensory Processing in People With and Without Tendinopathy: A Systematic Review With Meta-analysis of Local, Regional, and Remote Sites in Upper- and Lower-Limb Conditions Rio, E, Sandler, J., Cheng, K., Moseley, G. L., Cook, J., & Girdwood, M. (2021) Sensory processing in people with and without tendinopathy: A systematic review with meta-analysis…
Simple but Effective Ways Hand Therapists Address Psychosocial Impacts of Upper Extremity Injuries
Although psychosocial factors are often not formally assessed during an evaluation in those with upper extremity injuries, the therapist often informally assesses these during and after treatment sessions. Sustaining an upper extremity injury can be a physically and emotionally challenging experience. Beyond the physical pain and limitations, these injuries can profoundly impact an individual’s psychosocial…
Distal radius fracture types seen in the hand therapy clinic
Distal radius fractures are one of the most common injuries seen in hand therapy. Several different distal radius fracture classification systems have been developed, and this blog post will focus on the more common types of distal radius fractures and their classification. Extra-articular fractures are either nondisplaced or displaced fractures. These fractures occur outside…
Creating an Action Plan for Addressing Mental Health in the Clinic
Blog By: Rachel Reed As hand therapists, our care for our patients must be driven by the goal of treating the whole person, not just their hand or injury (Hannah, 2011). Occupational therapy is a unique profession in which we are equipped to view our patients through a holistic lens. With this lens, we are…
Sign-up to Get Updates Straight to Your Inbox!
Sign up with us and we will send you regular blog posts on everything hand therapy, notices every time we upload new videos and tutorials, along with handout, protocols, and other useful information.