Surgical vs. Conservative Treatment for Pediatric Trigger Finger

Jia, L., King, J. D., Goubeaux, C., Belardo, Z. E., Little, K. J., Samora, J. B., Marks, J., &
Shah, A. S. (2023). Presentation and management of the pediatric trigger finger: A
multicenter retrospective cohort study. The Journal of Hand Surgery, 48(7), 665–672.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhsa.2023.03.015

Article Review: Kelsy Melton

trigger finger

The Skinny: The goal of this study conducted by King et al., (2023) was to compare operative
and nonoperative treatment outcomes for pediatric trigger finger (PTF) based on presentation of the
condition. This is a rare and under-studied condition that can come from several anatomical
etiologies including the thickening of flexor digitorium profundus (FDP) and/or flexor digitorum superficialis (FDS), or an abnormal relationship between FDS or FDP, or constriction of the A1, A2 or A3 pulleys.

This was a retrospective cohort study conducted through the medical record review of three children’s
hospitals. The record review identified patient demographics, pediatric trigger finger characteristics, treatment strategies, and outcomes and ultimately included 321 patients 18 years and younger with a
combined total of 449 PTFs.

trigger finger

In the Weeds: Patients were excluded from the study if they had prior surgeries on the affected
digits or if they had a predisposing medical condition. Medical record reviews included patient
and pediatric trigger finger characteristics, nonsurgical treatment strategies, duration, and outcome, as well as operative treatment strategies, complications, and outcomes. Nonsurgical treatment strategies
included monitoring, stretching, nighttime extension splinting, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory
drugs, and corticosteroid injections. Operative treatment included A1, 2 and/or 3 pulley release,
ulnar and radial FDS slip excision, and mass/tumor removal. A statistical analysis of the reviewed
data was utilized to determine a difference in the resolution of symptoms between splinted vs.
non-splinted pediatric trigger finger. A second analysis was completed to determine the difference between A1 pulley release alone versus A1 pulley release in combination with other procedures.

Bringing it Home: 80% of patients pursued non-surgical management of pediatric trigger finger initially, but after persistent worsening of symptoms 20% of those patients sought surgical intervention. The most common nonsurgical management was extension splinting and monitoring, resulting in 75% of
these pediatric trigger fingers achieved complete resolution of symptoms within 6 months., but high-grade pediatric trigger figners were significantly less likely to achieve this complete resolution with non-surgical management.

Overall, it was found that pediatric trigger fingers managed operatively had significantly higher rates of complete resolution compared with those managed conservatively. This confirmed the authors’ hypothesis that operatively managed pediatric trigger fingers have a significantly higher rate of symptom resolution than conservatively managed pediatric trigger fingers.

Rating: Overall, this study receives a 3 out of 5 rating. The large sample size and significant
findings of this study provide valuable insight into the treatment of a historically under-studied
condition. One of the biggest limitations of the study involves the potential for bias due to it
being a retrospective review. It is also possible that these findings are not generalizable to
patients with a predisposing medical condition, since these individuals were excluded from the
study.

Leave a Comment






More To Read

Conservative Management of Carpal Tunnel Symptoms: A Comparison of the effectiveness of orthosis wear, kinesiotaping and paraffin treatment.

September 21, 2019

Kaplan, B. M., Akyuz, G., Kokar, S., & Yagci, I. (2018). Comparison of the effectiveness of orthotic intervention, kinesiotaping, and paraffin treatments in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome: A single-blind and randomized controlled study. Journal of Hand Therapy, 32, 297-304. The Skinny The authors completed a randomized control trial with three groups to test the…

Read More

An evaluation of wrist and forearm range of motion during purposeful activities and exercises for distal radius fracture

December 19, 2022

An evaluation of wrist and forearm movement during purposeful activities and range of movement exercises after surgical repair of a distal radius fracture: A randomized crossover study Collis, J.,  Mayland, E.,  Wright-St Clair, V.,  Rashid, U., Kayes, N., & Signal, N. 2022. An evaluation of wrist and forearm movement during purposeful activities and range of…

Read More

How to Improve Fine Motor Translation Skills

January 16, 2022

By: Josh MacDonald The Basics – I lay a pile of small objects on the table and an open container for the client to put them into. What object I use depends on the client’s level. We’ll get to that later. Then, they use a 2-point pincer grasp to pick up one and shift it…

Read More
Envelope_1

Sign-up to Get Updates Straight to Your Inbox!

Sign up with us and we will send you regular blog posts on everything hand therapy, notices every time we upload new videos and tutorials, along with handout, protocols, and other useful information.