What are the minimally important changes of four commonly used patient-reported outcome measures for 36 hand and wrist condition-treatment combinations

hand therapy outcome measures

Article Review By: Case Peters


Hoogendam, L., Koopman, J.E., van Kooj, Y.E., Feitz, R., Hundepool, C.A., Zhou, C. … The Hand Wrist Study Group (2021) What are the minimally important changes of four commonly used patient-reported outcome measures for 36 hand and wrist condition-treatment combinations. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research. epub ahead of print. doi: 10.1097/CORR.0000000000002094. 

The Skinny

Prior research has shown that the minimal clinically important difference (MCID) for several patient-reported outcome measures (PROMS) / hand therapy outcome measures can vary greatly depending on the patient’s condition and the treatment provided. This article sets out to establish the MCID for several commonly-used PROMS for a variety of hand and wrist conditions. 

In the Weeds

The authors establish two primary questions: 1) What are the MCIDs for some of the most frequently used PROMS for common condition-treatment combinations in the hand/wrist; 2) Does the MCID vary depending on the invasiveness of treatment (i.e. surgical vs. conservative management). 

The authors reviewed a database of 23,749 patients with 22 different hand and wrist conditions treated with a spectrum of nonsurgical, minor surgical, and major surgical interventions. The MCID scores were established for 36 condition-treatment combinations. The MCIDs for the surgical and non-surgical group were compared with a Wilcoxon signed rank test to determine if there was a difference between surgical and nonsurgical treatment. 

Outcome Measures

Patient-Reported Outcome MeasureSubscalesIncluded Conditions
Pain Visual Analogue Scale (0-100)Pain at rest Pain with load Average painAll
Hand Function: Visual Analogue Scale (0-100)None All
Michigan Hand outcomes Questionnaire (0-100)Hand function score Work score ADL score Pain score Aesthetics score Satisfaction scoreFinger and Thumb conditionsCMC OA, Trigger Finger, etc. 
Patient-rated Wrist/Hand Evaluation (0-100)Pain score function score Wrist conditions, Midcarpal Instability, etc.
Boston Carpal Tunnel Questionnaire (1-5)Symptom severity scale functional status scaleNerve conditions Carpal tunnelCubital tunnel

Bringing it home

The MCID is an important measure of clinical significance. It helps give us insight into the smallest level of change in a treatment outcome that a patient would identify as important

The authors conclude that the MCID varies depending on the condition and the invasiveness of the procedure. In general, MCID values for nonsurgical treatment were approximately 1/9th of the scale, while MCID values for surgical treatment were approximately 1/5th of the scale. Patients receiving more invasive treatment more likely have higher treatment expectations may be in more discomfort or may feel that the return on investment from a more invasive treatment should yield a greater improvement

Rating (0-5 rating scale):

Rating is 4/5. The standard caveats and limitations apply for any retrospective, non-randomized controlled trial. However, the researchers were very thorough and transparent in their methodology and were forthcoming about the potential limitations of this work. Establishing these condition-treatment-specific MCID values can help clinicians with goal-writing, setting patient expectations, and understanding the patient perception of what constitutes a beneficial treatment. 

The authors have also created a free online tool to share their results that anyone can access. Clinicians can use this resource to quickly review the MCID values for any condition-treatment combinations relevant to their practice. Access it below.

Minimal Important Change for multiple PROMS and treatments for hand and wrist disorders 

Leave a Comment

More To Read

Is therapy needed after a distal radius fracture?

July 24, 2021

Coughlin T, Norrish AR, Scammell BE, Matthews PA, Nightingale J, Ollivere BJ. Comparison of rehabilitation interventions in nonoperatively treated distal radius fractures: a randomized controlled trial of effectiveness. Bone Joint J. 2021Jun;103-B(6):1033-1039. doi: 10.1302/0301-620X.103B.BJJ-2020-2026.R1.Epub 2021 Apr 30. PMID: 33926211. The Skinny: Individuals with distal radius fractures are very common in the hand therapy world. This…

Read More

Conservative Management of Carpal Tunnel Symptoms: A Comparison of the effectiveness of orthosis wear, kinesiotaping and paraffin treatment.

September 21, 2019

Kaplan, B. M., Akyuz, G., Kokar, S., & Yagci, I. (2018). Comparison of the effectiveness of orthotic intervention, kinesiotaping, and paraffin treatments in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome: A single-blind and randomized controlled study. Journal of Hand Therapy, 32, 297-304. The Skinny The authors completed a randomized control trial with three groups to test the…

Read More

Article Review: Trapeziectomy and LRTI: What can patients with CMC osteoarthritis expect 12 months after the procedure?

October 10, 2021

Janakiramanan, N., Miles, O., Collon, S., Crammond, B., McCombe, D., & Tham, S. K. (2021). Functional Recovery Following Trapeziectomy and Ligament Reconstruction and Tendon Interposition (Trapeziectomy and LRTI): A Prospective Longitudinal Study. The Journal of hand surgery, S0363-5023(21)00304-X. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhsa.2021.04.036 The skinny: Patients with trapeziometacarpal (TMC) osteoarthritis who are candidates for a trapeziectomy and…

Read More

Sign-up to Get Updates Straight to Your Inbox!

Sign up with us and we will send you regular blog posts on everything hand therapy, notices every time we upload new videos and tutorials, along with handout, protocols, and other useful information.