Which orthosis design is better for zone 5-6 extensor tendon injuries, a relative motion orthosis compared to a dynamic extension orthosis?
Filed under Reviews
M. Buhler, ˝ D. Gwynne-Jones, M. Chin et al., (2023) Are the outcomes of relative motion extension orthoses noninferior and cost-effective compared with dynamic extension orthoses for management of zones V-VI finger extensor tendon repairs: A randomizedcontrolledtrialJournalofHandTherapy.
The Skinny: The aim of this study was to compare the data for two different types of orthoses for treating a zone 5-6 extensor tendon injury. Type one was a relative motion orthosis (RMO) plus, meaning the utilization of an RMO and a wrist support together. The second time was a dynamic wrist hand finger orthosis. Participant in both groups were fitted with a nighttime extension orthosis
In the Weeds: There were a total of 37 participants in the study with a mean age of 39 years old with an extensor tendon repair in zone five or six. The study design was a parallel group non-inferiority randomized controlled trial design. Non-inferiority design is used when an alternate intervention is not any worse than the current established treatment.
Outcome measures included primary and secondary outcomes. The primary outcome measure was the total active range of motion (TAM), and the secondary outcomes included patient satisfaction, Quickdash and quality of life. These were measured at 6 and 12 weeks post-operative. Grip strength was only assessed at 12 weeks.
Image from article M. Bu ̋hler, D. Gwynne-Jones, M. Chin et al./Journal of Hand Therapy. Image A, B, and C depicts the dynamic orthosis group & image D, E, and F depicts the RMO plus group
Brining it Home:
There were no statistical differences in total active range of motion, orthotic or outcome satisfaction. Patient in the RMO plus group were more compliant in wearing the RMO plus compared to those wearing the dynamic orthosis. On average participants returned to work in both groups at 7 weeks post-operative. During the study there were two tendon ruptures in the RMO plus orthosis group compared to one in the dynamic orthosis group.
RMO plus management of extensor tendon injuries was determined to be non inferior to the dynamic orthosis group in terms of all outcome measures.
Rating : 4/5
Limitations to this study include the small sample size as well as the fact that all study participants were males showing a lack of generalizability. However even with the limitations of the study, it was shown that each patient group had equal findings and both types of orthotic designs are safe to use with zone 5 and 6 extensor tendons.
More To Read
Do you know the secret ingredient to recovering from an injury?
Do you know the secret ingredient to recovering from an injury? I will give you a hint it is 5 letters and begins with the letter S. SLEEP Have you ever asked yourself a question – does sleep help injuries heal? This is for you to share with your patients but also serve as a…
Effectiveness of Conservative Therapy and Splinting for 1st CMC OA
Tsehaie, J., Sprekraijse, K., Wouters, R., Slijper, H., Feitz, R., Hovious, S., & Selles, R. (2018). Outcome of a Hand Orthosis and Hand Therapy for Carpometacarpal Osteoarthritis in Daily Practice: A Prospective Cohort Study. American Society for Surgery of the Hand, 1-11. The skinny: Non-surgical approaches (hand therapy & orthotics) are typically the go-to for…
A Better De Quervain’s Tenosynovitis Test
J. F. Goubau, L. Goubau, A. Van Tongel, P. Van Hoonacker, D. Kerckhove, B. Berghs (2013).The wrist hyperflexion and abduction of the thumb (WHAT) test: a more specific and sensitive test to diagnose de Quervain tenosynovitis than the Eichhoff’s Test. J Hand Surg Eur Vol. 2014 Mar; 39(3): 286–292. Published online 2013 Jan 22. doi:…
Simple but Effective Ways Hand Therapists Address Psychosocial Impacts of Upper Extremity Injuries
Although psychosocial factors are often not formally assessed during an evaluation in those with upper extremity injuries, the therapist often informally assesses these during and after treatment sessions. Sustaining an upper extremity injury can be a physically and emotionally challenging experience. Beyond the physical pain and limitations, these injuries can profoundly impact an individual’s psychosocial…
Sign-up to Get Updates Straight to Your Inbox!
Sign up with us and we will send you regular blog posts on everything hand therapy, notices every time we upload new videos and tutorials, along with handout, protocols, and other useful information.